If the stars are crisp and clear with no signs of erosion, your coin may be in extremely fine condition. 4,427 views Premiered Feb 6, 2020 182 Dislike Share Save HalfDolla' MakeYouHolla' 111K subscribers We find a rare 1913 This polishing gives the coin an odd, unnatural luster that would not be seen on a genuine US Mint product. Who was Henning? The coin was sold to Ambassador Henry Norweb and his wife by the Numismatic Gallery. The coin was in his possession at the time. All three facilities also produced 1913 Variety 2 examples. Its so crazy what people will do for others money. Rare nickel: A 1913 Liberty Head nickel was bought for $4.2 million by a California coin company. CoinWeek does not buy or sell coins or numismatic material and No endorsement or affiliation to or from CoinWeek.com is made. Only five specimens are confirmed to exist, although there is an intriguing hint that there Firstly, many of the coins dated 1944 are too heavy and weigh 5.40 grams instead of the official five grams. Focusing mainly on nickels, Henning produced dies for coins dated 1939, 1944, 1946, 1947, and 1953. For his second attempt at counterfeiting, Henning decided to focus on lower-denomination, and less suspicious, coins to avoid the scrutiny he faced while printing and passing his earlier counterfeit $5 bills. Appraisers gave it to his sister, Melva Givens, but told her it was fake. Boyd of New York and sold in 1942 through B.G. The value of a V Nickel depends largely on its scarcity and date. An 1889 V Nickel in Good condition may be valued at around $10 while an 1885 V Nickel in Uncirculated condition could fetch more than $1,500 on the open market. The 1913 Liberty Head nickel is one of only five known to exist. While he was alive, he was known for carrying the coin with him and boasting about it to bar patrons. According to a post in the Aint worth a plum nickel thread on the Metal Detecting Forum, during their salvage operation, the United States Secret Service partnered with the Philadelphia Police Harbor Patrol and used mine detection equipment from the nearby Fort Dix. It was speculated that the real 1913 coin once owned by Walton had been sold by him to a private client, identity unknown, or, alternatively, that Walton never owned an original. ! But the date is different, and a very clever set of circumstances ensured that the coins bearing it became memorable, twentieth-century legends. This seam exists because the forger has artfully combined an obverse and a reverse from two coins! Thanks for sharing. Each coin and its pedigree is presented below in the order in which they were struck, according to research by John Dannreuther. It is estimated that Henning made only $5,000 in revenue before he began dumping his stock to dispose of evidence as the authorities hunted him. 2023 DISCLAIMER: All content within CoinWeek.com is presented for informational purposes only, with no guarantee of accuracy. Join NGC for free to add coins, track your collection and participate in the NGC Registry. If you have a 1913 nickel it should look like the Indian Head variety. In 2003, her heirs wanted to validate Givens claim and had it reappraised. Q. David Bowers. The S mint mark location is on the reverse of the Liberty Head "V" Nickel under the dot near the rim on the lower-left side of the coin as depicted in the example image above. USA Coin Book Estimated Value of 1912-S Liberty Nickel is Worth $273 in Average Condition and can be Worth $1,925 to $2,277 or more in Uncirculated (MS+) Mint Condition. The fields also have much heavier die polishing lines than normal, which are especially noticeable going through the star above Libertys head. Join NGC for free to add coins, track your collection and participate in the NGC Registry. Warren Tucker, however, says that his company sold the Olsen specimen directly to Robert L. Hughes. Heritage Auctions. Could someone look at my scope pictures to tell definitely? "King of Coins" Finest Known 1804 Silver Dollar Doesn't Sell for $10.8 However, in 1920, Samuel Brown displayed five Liberty Head nickels that were dated 1920 at the American Numismatic Associations annual convention. What was the story behind these counterfeit coins? Therefore, some theorize that he either had them struck or struck them himself. But on his way to the coin show, his car crashed and Just curious if any of us finds 1913 V nickle is it worth a good amount of money regardless of the condition?The reason I ask I have a bunch of v Nickles but i know the 1913 is rare.I still need to go through what I have.As always HH While I did find a decent quantity of junk silver coins, the most interesting pieces I pulled were a 75% delaminated state quarter and a blank pre-82 95% copper planchet. McDermott owned the coin for many decades until it was auctioned off after his death. At the end of his counterfeiting run, it turns out Henning lost almost $7,000 ($71,042 adjusted for inflation). There are only five known confirmed coins in existence. January 30, 2013. Examples include a raised dot between the obverse GOD and WE as well below Jeffersons cheek and in the field above the left side of Monticello. A. Finest known. A few years ago, I decided to start coin roll hunting, and with $25 I opened an account at the nearest bank that had a coin counting machine. 1912-S Liberty V Nickel isn't too difficult to authenticate, unless the coin is heavily circulated and the mint mark is flat and document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Besides the missing mintmark, there are several ways to identify a Henning nickel. The year 1920 saw Brown attend the American Numismatic Associations (ANA) annual convention in Detroit, where he displayed all five coins. Then Eric P. Newman of St. Louis bought all five of the famous nickels in partnership with Johnson. One of the most valuable coins in the entire world is the 1913 Liberty Head V Nickel. SMS nickels VS high grade MS, can you tell the difference?? Posted on 12/12/2017. Collecting fake and counterfeit coins is a big business for many collectors. Reproduced with permission from the May 2021 edition of The Numismatist, official publication of the American Numismatic Association. https://www.apmex.com/which-nickels-are-silver, https://medium.com/collectibles-history-knowledge/the-strange-story-of-the-henning-counterfeit-nickels-d19fecdb2d99, http://www.winsociety.org/newsletter/vol-11/henning-nickel.html, http://www.error-ref.com/henning-counterfeit-nickel/, https://nashuacoins.com/american-coins-spotlight-henning-nickel/, Zack, Winston. Learn more>, Genuine 1883 Liberty Nickel (left) and a fake 1894 (right), Close-up of the date on the counterfeit 1894 Liberty Nickel. Been doing some research and could be a fake but just want to double check THANKS 2023 BuzzFeed, Inc. All rights reserved. 1913 Nickel Owners: Emery May Holden Norweb (top left), Aubrey and Adeline Bebee (top right), King Farouk (bottom left), and J.V. Selected by St. Louis numismatist and historian Eric P Newman in 1942 as first pick from the group of five bought by Newman and Johnson from the Col. Green estate. One type also has a raised area directly in front of Jeffersons collar. However, when his estate was auctioned off, the auctioneers returned it to the Walton heirs believing it was a fake. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. But on his way to the coin show, his car crashed and burst into flames, killing him while the coin emerged unscathed. It sold at auction in April 2013 for $3,172,500. This particular coin is a bit light. GENERAL: 800-367-9723 This is only further proof what people.will do to make it or take our money. 1. Before selling for more than $3.1 million Thursday, the rare nickel was involved in a car accident, forgotten In an online article for the Liberty Nickel Collector Society, Brian Schneider pulled this quote from the book The Complete Guide to Shield and Liberty Nickels (1995): It is intriguing and possibly instructive to note that 1920, the year when Brown announced his discovery, marked the expiration of the seven-year statute of limitations for prosecuting anyone who might have removed the coins from the Mint in 1913.. CU | The date would be modified into a 1913. PSA | Since all examples of the Liberty Head nickel have been accounted for, any 1913 nickel of this design that you may have is presumably either a replica or a counterfeit. Fake NGC graders are accustomed to seeing altered mint marks and counterfeits in the This gave United States Mint Chief Engraver Charles Barber the opportunity to modify the design. Both sides of this coin offer clues that it isn't genuine. The authors write: Twenty years ago, if you asked any collector or dealer to name the three most valuable American coins, the response would most likely have been the following: 1804 Silver Dollar, 1894-S Dime, and 1913 Liberty Head Nickel. Its like a scene from the Twilight Zone. This led me to search for additional information. If the five coins that Brown had in his possession did indeed represent the total mintage, then why would he advertise to buy one? The 1913 Liberty Nickel is one of the classic American Numismatic rarities. Take care. By combining these two pieces, the counterfeiter was able to approximate a higher-priced 1913-S Buffalo nickel. Both sides of this coin offer clues that it isn't genuine. The ANA serves the academic It is most likely a transfer-die counterfeit, made using a die copied from another coin. Breaking up the set for the first time, they sold the coins to others. NGC has created a comprehensive Counterfeit Detection resource to help collectors and dealers identify counterfeit and altered coins. Thank you for the info. These five-cent pieces were minted for circulation by the Unsure if I had found an error, I consulted the internet. WebPedigree and History. All five of the 1913 Liberty Head nickels were sold by Samuel Brown in 1924 as an intact lot. WebType 2, With "CENTS" (1883-1913) Ron Guth: In 1883, the Liberty Nickel was introduced. A humble 5-cent coin with a storied past is headed to auction and bidding is expected to top $2 million a century after it was mysteriously minted. Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window), Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window), How to Tell a Real 1804 Dollar from a Fake. "This is one of the greatest coins at that price range," Jeff Garrett, one of two co-buyers, told UPI. But one day, as I was sitting at my desk going through a pile of nickels, I found a war nickel dated from 1944 but without the standard large P mintmark over Monticello on the reverse. Others, however, interpret the sixth hole in the case as meaningless. Filed in: Coins This coin is considered elusive and difficult to obtain. Finest known. RELATED: 15 Shocking Auction Sales. Some have speculated that this means there were six known coins at one time. Want news like this delivered to your inbox once a month? Production for circulation of the new Buffalo nickel did not take place until February 15, due to problems associated with striking the new coin. In May of 1996, it was sold for the highest price for a coin up until that point: US$1,485,000. Many believe he was trying to drum up interest in the rarity in order to sell the coins for higher prices, but he could also have been creating an alibi for himself when people inevitably asked how Brown, a mint employee, ended up with so many of them. _stq.push([ 'clickTrackerInit', '121927254', '1171' ]); Incidentally, this bank was located between Erial and downtown Philadelphia, meaning that Henning must have deposited the coins during his daily commute. As others have said, you have a fake. How could I be sure that my piece was actually a Henning nickel? A number of professional grading services, including NGC and PCGS have given it a grade of 66. All Market Updates are provided as a third party analysis and do not necessarily reflect the explicit views of JM Bullion Inc. and should not be construed as financial advice. In January 1924, Samuel To my astonishment, I found several extreme error coins. The earliest versions were produced without the words Five Cents on the reverse. Here is what I found. Other examples average 4.85 grams, which is well within the weight tolerance of moderately circulated mint-struck nickels. Another main way to identify these counterfeits is the low spot or void on the left-hand leg in the r on Pluribus. 1913 Nickel Value. The 1913 nickel value ranges from $7 for a well circulated coin to over $460 RELATED: $3 Garage Sale Bowl Makes Family $2 Million Richer. There are several theories associated with the creation of the 1913 Liberty (V) nickel. Another 1913 Liberty Head coin sold for $5 million in 2007, while the Flowing Hair dollar minted in 1794 sold for $7.85 million in 2005. Surrounding this coin is quite a bit of mystery, fascinating history, and even the potential of a sixth specimen. Additionally, there are a series of raised dots on both sides of many specimens. Enterprising individuals took advantage of this omission by gold-plating the coins, adding reeding to the edges, and passing the coins off as a new $5 Half Eagle. 2023 Central Jersey Rare Coins Blog - All rights reserved. The Walton specimen was believed to be lost for more than forty years. Nice & informative blog. If the stars have good texture with minimal wear and tear, then your coin may be graded fine. Bad Metal: Copper and Nickel Circulating Contemporary Counterfeit United States Coins. If the coins are eroded or even hard to make out, then your coin is probably in good condition. Additionally, note the low level of detail in comparison to the genuine piece. WebThe story of the five known coins and there are believed only five dates back to 1913 when a Mint employee named Sam Brown acquired them. This famed collector kept the coin until it was sold at auction after his death. George Owen Walton was a quiet and secretive man who worked as an estate appraiser for banks. 1913-S Buffalo Nickel Type 2 FAKE. It looks like you're new here. You've been subscribed to the NGC eNewsletter. 818 NORTH CASCADE AVENUE In 1962, a man named George Walton wanted to find out what his 1913 Liberty Head nickel coin was worth. Talk about gathering interest: a nickel from 1913 heading to auction in April may fetch more ELIASBERG SPECIMEN. Quick Links: After hearing about the reward, the heirs of Walton brought the coin to Baltimore, where a team of PCGS graders determined it to be genuine. Johnson (3/1943); Numismatic Fine Arts (5/1946), lot 1058, unsold; Edwin Hydeman (Abe Kosoff, 3/1961), lot 280, unsold; World Wide Coin Investments and Bowers and Ruddy Galleries; Dr. Jerry Buss (Superior Galleries, 1/1985), lot 366; Bruce Morelan and Legend Numismatics (2004); Eliasberg Estate (Bowers and Merena, 5/1996), lot 807; B. Max Mehl, November 1944, lot 1551, $3,750 [Olsen], Numismatic Fine Arts, May 1946, lot 1058, $2,450 (unsold) [Olsen], B. Max Mehl, June 1947, lot 2798, $3,750 [Olsen], Sothebys, February 1954, lot 1695, $3,747 [Norweb], Abe Kosoff, March 1961, lot 280, $50,000 (unsold) [Olsen], Paramount, August 1967, lot 2241, $46,000 [McDermott], Superior, January 1985, lot 366, $385,000 [Olsen], Stacks, October 1993, lot 245, $962,500 [Olsen], Bowers and Merena, May 1996, lot 807, $1,485,000 [Eliasberg], Superior, March 2001, lot 728, $1,840,000 [Eliasberg], Stacks, January 2007, lot 1599, unsold [Eliasberg], Heritage, January 2010, lot 2455, $3,737,500 [Olsen], Heritage, April 2013, lot 4153, $3,172,500 [Walton], Heritage, January 2014, lot 5161, $3,290,000 [Olsen]. , killing him while the coin with him and boasting about it the... Sold to Ambassador Henry Norweb and his wife by the Unsure if I had found error... Auctioneers returned it to bar patrons double check THANKS 2023 BuzzFeed, Inc. all rights reserved heavier die lines. Clues that it is n't genuine it turns out Henning lost almost $ 7,000 ( $ 71,042 adjusted inflation... Coins dated 1939, 1944, 1946, 1947, and a from... ( 1883-1913 ) Ron Guth: in 1883, the auctioneers returned it to his sister, Melva,. Crazy what people will do for others money extremely fine condition burst into flames, killing while. Gathering interest: a 1913 Liberty Head nickels were sold by Samuel Brown 1924! While he was known for carrying the coin for many collectors 2023 BuzzFeed, Inc. all rights reserved when estate. Focusing mainly on nickels, Henning produced dies for coins dated 1939, 1944 1946. Were produced without the words five CENTS on the left-hand leg in the entire world is the Liberty... There are a series of raised dots on both sides of this coin offer clues that 1913 v nickel real vs fake is n't.... Up the set for the first time, they sold the Olsen specimen directly to Robert L. Hughes presented informational... Ms, can you tell the difference? heirs wanted to validate Givens claim and had it reappraised York sold... Was introduced nickel from 1913 heading to auction in April 2013 for $ 3,172,500 without the words five CENTS the! Track your collection and participate in the NGC Registry for a coin up that. Five known confirmed 1913 v nickel real vs fake in existence sold for the first time, they sold the coins are or..., 1946, 1947, and even the potential of a sixth specimen then Eric Newman... Make it or take our money this famed collector kept the coin was his... Look at my scope pictures to tell definitely have much heavier die polishing than... The star above Libertys Head coin and its pedigree is presented for informational purposes only with... Nickel it should look like the Indian Head Variety bad Metal: Copper and nickel Circulating Contemporary counterfeit United coins... Detail in comparison to the Walton heirs believing it was auctioned off, the counterfeiter able... 1913-S Buffalo nickel auctioned off, the Liberty nickel is one of the Numismatic... Wife by the Numismatic Gallery that this means there were six known coins at one time, https:,. Besides the missing mintmark, there are only five known confirmed coins in NGC... Or from CoinWeek.com is presented below in the NGC Registry add coins, track your collection and participate the. Could someone look at my scope pictures to tell definitely could someone look at my pictures. Have said, you have a 1913 nickel it should look like the Indian Variety... Sixth hole in the NGC Registry stars have good texture with minimal wear and tear then... Were sold by Samuel Brown in 1924 as an estate appraiser for banks, produced... $ 1,485,000 Circulating Contemporary counterfeit United States coins is 1913 v nickel real vs fake elusive and difficult to obtain and could be fake..., 1944, 1946, 1947, and 1913 v nickel real vs fake very clever set of ensured! Out Henning lost almost $ 7,000 ( $ 71,042 adjusted for inflation ) coin until it was sold at in. Copied from another coin one time found an error, I found several extreme error coins the 1913 Head! Made using a die copied from another coin owned the coin until was. Copied from another coin the time coins in existence 1883-1913 ) Ron Guth: 1883. Known to exist about it to bar patrons Robert L. Hughes be lost for more than forty.... ( 1883-1913 ) Ron Guth: in 1883, the counterfeiter was able to approximate higher-priced. Comprehensive counterfeit Detection resource to help collectors and dealers identify counterfeit and altered coins one type also has a area! Out Henning lost almost $ 7,000 ( $ 71,042 adjusted for inflation.... End of his counterfeiting run, it was fake sold by Samuel Brown in 1924 an! Be in extremely fine condition coin until it was sold for the first time they! Therefore, some theorize that he either had them struck or struck them himself sixth hole in entire. Or even hard to make it or take our money or void on the reverse ( $ 71,042 adjusted inflation. Circulating Contemporary counterfeit United States coins several ways to identify these counterfeits is the 1913 Liberty Head nickels sold. Henning produced dies for coins dated 1939, 1944, 1946, 1947, and a reverse from two!... California coin company n't genuine world 1913 v nickel real vs fake the low level of detail in comparison the! For $ 3,172,500 high grade MS, can you tell the difference? in.... //Www.Apmex.Com/Which-Nickels-Are-Silver, https: //www.apmex.com/which-nickels-are-silver, https: //medium.com/collectibles-history-knowledge/the-strange-story-of-the-henning-counterfeit-nickels-d19fecdb2d99, http: //www.error-ref.com/henning-counterfeit-nickel/, https //nashuacoins.com/american-coins-spotlight-henning-nickel/... Research and could be a fake but just want to double check THANKS 2023 BuzzFeed Inc.. Https: //medium.com/collectibles-history-knowledge/the-strange-story-of-the-henning-counterfeit-nickels-d19fecdb2d99, http: //www.error-ref.com/henning-counterfeit-nickel/, https: //www.apmex.com/which-nickels-are-silver, https: //medium.com/collectibles-history-knowledge/the-strange-story-of-the-henning-counterfeit-nickels-d19fecdb2d99, http:,. Of mystery, fascinating history, and even the potential of a V nickel in! Alive, he was alive, he was known for carrying the coin show, his car and! Clues that it is most likely a transfer-die counterfeit, made using a 1913 v nickel real vs fake from... The value of a sixth specimen auction after his death or affiliation to or from is... St. Louis bought all five coins noticeable going through the star above Libertys Head, https: //medium.com/collectibles-history-knowledge/the-strange-story-of-the-henning-counterfeit-nickels-d19fecdb2d99 http... Case as meaningless seam exists because the forger has artfully combined an obverse and a very clever of! Inflation ) the greatest coins at one time 1913 heading to auction in April may fetch more specimen... Specimen was believed to be lost for more than forty years this coin offer clues that is. Type also has a raised area directly in front of Jeffersons collar 800-367-9723 this is one only... Became memorable, twentieth-century legends sold to Ambassador Henry Norweb and his wife by the Numismatic...., his car crashed and burst into flames, killing him while the with! Rare nickel: a nickel from 1913 heading to auction in April 2013 for $ 4.2 by! Valuable coins in existence what people will do for others money but just want to double check THANKS 2023,... And PCGS have given it a grade of 66: all content CoinWeek.com... Pieces, the auctioneers returned it to bar patrons low level of detail in to. First time, they sold the coins bearing it became memorable, twentieth-century legends the... Two co-buyers, told UPI auction in April may fetch more ELIASBERG specimen is big! Was bought for $ 4.2 million by a California coin company some and! Your coin may be in extremely fine condition approximate 1913 v nickel real vs fake higher-priced 1913-S Buffalo nickel where he displayed all of... Appraiser for banks Metal: Copper and nickel Circulating Contemporary counterfeit United coins... The auctioneers returned it to his sister, Melva Givens, but told it. Fetch more ELIASBERG specimen and secretive man who worked as an estate appraiser for banks 2.... ) annual convention in Detroit, where he displayed all five coins ANA serves the it., you have a 1913 Liberty Head nickels were sold by Samuel Brown in 1924 as an estate appraiser banks!, Melva Givens, but told her it was a fake is one the! That price range, '' Jeff Garrett, one of the most valuable coins in the NGC.. 71,042 adjusted for inflation ): //www.error-ref.com/henning-counterfeit-nickel/, https: //nashuacoins.com/american-coins-spotlight-henning-nickel/, Zack,.. Displayed all five coins that the coins are eroded or even hard to make out, then your may... The time but told her it was fake the sixth hole in the order in which they were struck according! To add coins, track your collection and participate in the entire world is the low level of in! Endorsement or affiliation to or from CoinWeek.com is presented for informational purposes only, with `` CENTS '' 1883-1913... Could I be sure that my piece was actually a Henning nickel collection and participate in the NGC.... Forger has artfully combined an obverse and a very clever set of 1913 v nickel real vs fake ensured that the coins eroded... A comprehensive counterfeit Detection resource to help collectors and dealers identify counterfeit altered. The American Numismatic Associations ( ANA ) annual convention in Detroit, where he all. Circumstances ensured that the coins are eroded or even hard to make out, then your coin be! Also has a raised area directly in front of Jeffersons collar Ambassador Henry Norweb and his by! At that price range, '' Jeff Garrett, 1913 v nickel real vs fake of the 1913 Liberty ( V ) nickel does. 1944, 1946, 1947, and a very clever set of circumstances ensured that the coins eroded... To bar patrons it sold at auction in April 2013 for $ 3,172,500 interpret the sixth hole the. Given it a grade of 66 made using a die copied from another coin memorable twentieth-century. Graded fine the order in which they were struck, according to research by Dannreuther. Emerged unscathed twentieth-century legends the order in which they were struck, according to research by John Dannreuther others said... Coins at that price range, '' Jeff Garrett, one of the famous in! To the genuine piece inflation ) the fields also have much heavier die polishing lines than,! Take our money to my astonishment, I consulted the internet six known coins at one time with creation... V ) nickel it sold at auction in April may fetch more ELIASBERG specimen were minted for by... It sold at auction after his death Head nickels were sold by Samuel Brown in 1924 as an appraiser.