Steve and Peggy Carter are the ultimate tragic love story that turned out to have a happy ending after all. Hes supposed to return to 2023 after his mission is done, but he remains in the past to live his life with Peggy Carter (Hayley Atwell). Instead, Steve kept the truth hidden and it led to the Avengers breaking apart when Tony finally found out. But what about Peggys grandniece Sharon Carter (Emily VanCamp), who had a romance with Steve? We learn that Steve stayed in the past and lived . Based on the chronology, by the time that Sam would have been fighting age, Steve Rogers would already be elderly and probably ready to hand off the mantle. The Agent Carter husband mystery The romance between Steve and Peggy was tragically cut short at the end of The First. Recently, I did a post about why Captain America's shield was round and I noted that there was a Captain America/Black Panther miniseries that offered an explanation. The explanation for the two heroes not recognizing each other (and Namor not recognizing the concept of Captain America in general) are tied into other stories from the Silver Age, one before Avengers #4 and one after. The Russo brothers explained that Steve lived out this life with Peggy in an alternate reality, butAvengers: Endgame's writers Christopher Markus and Stephen McFeely said otherwise. All the while, another Cap fought the battles weve seen before. All the latest gaming news, game reviews and trailers. In Endgame, Bruce explained to the team some of the laws of time travel. After being unfrozen at . Hercules: The Titans headed the wrong direction because they assumed Zeus was on Mt. Could the Avengers go back in time to kill baby Thanos? Now, the directors and writers have confirmed that there was one other person who knew about the plan. In 1986, Marvel debuted Marvel Saga, an ambitious re-telling of the Marvel Age of Comics by historian Peter Sanderson, using actual Marvel Comics to tell the story of the Marvel Universe in chronological order. What was the secret he was asking she knew? Yes, it couldn't have been easy and he wanted to protect Bucky. At this point in the timeline we know that she has died, his story with her never crossed his story with Sam. Each individuals future is definitive. And it is because he needed to keep this secret that future Steve did not tell Sam Wilson (Anthony Mackie) the truth about his wife when Sam questioned him about his wedding ring at the end of Endgame. Evenifthis ending was locked in stone back whenThe Winter Soldierwas made, there's no other option for Peggy than to lie to Steve about his future. Evans even managed to change his voice into a hushed rasp without any audio adjustments. Hiding from soldiers looking for him, Steve sneaks into an office and sees an old photo of him on the desk. Iron Man may have kickstarted the MCU but it was Captain America who was the first superhero, the original Avenger, long before any of the other superheroes first suited up and started taking down bad guys. Future US, Inc. Full 7th Floor, 130 West 42nd Street, For instance, the whole where did Cap go? question could very well be answered in the animated What If series that Marvel is developing for Disney+, based on something its been doing in comics for a while. He features legends about entertainment and sports at his website, Legends Revealed and other pop culture features at Pop Culture References. And when he found out she was alive, he was just lucky to have her. But he had enough time to come up with a way how to tell Tony what really happened and explain that Bucky was brainwashed and not responsible for his actions. It also explains why Cap didn't know who Black Panther was, as he somehow didn't put two and two together on T'Challa being connected to T'Chaka. Iron Man may have kickstarted the MCU but it was Captain America who was the first superhero, the original Avenger, long before any of the other superheroes first suited . But the only one who even vaguely succeeds and wipes the smug smile off Thor's face is Steve who budges the hammer but doesn't lift it. Steve knew that Bucky was the one who killed Tony's parents but even though he and Tony were friends at the time, he didn't tell him the truth. This story was a revised version of the first meeting between Captain America and T'Chaka, T'Challa's FATHER in Black Panther #30 (by Christopher Priest and Norm Breyfogle). Now we don't know the extent to which what Steve told him, but clearly, he told him something. Every Iron Man suit in the Marvel Cinematic Universe, and their comic roots, Destroying the Infinity Stones is next to impossible, at least in the comics, A history of Marvel comics heroes whove dared to wield the Infinity Gauntlet, What the comics tell us about Falcons Avengers: Endgame ending, Avengers: Endgame finally gives Pepper Potts one of her famous comic moments, The worthy heroes who have wielded Thors hammer in the comics. A subreddit dedicated to the Marvel Cinematic Universe! Cooper Hood is a news and feature writer for Screen Rant. A while back, I did a feature about when Captain America and Namor first met each other in Marvel's continuity. [This story contains spoilers for Avengers: Endgame.]. Avengers: Endgame is now available in Digital HD and comes to Blu-ray (opens in new tab) August 13. But maybe it's just because he felt his home was gone and coming back to modern-day Brooklyn would be too painful for him, it's difficult to say. Wouldn't you tell your friends about stuff like that? After all, he works for the S.H.I.E.L.D. He also is an avid lover of M&M McFlurries from McDonalds, and accepts that he has an addiction to them. It also seems pretty clear that the . Time with her is what hes always wanted, and its only natural he jumps at the chance to get it at the end of the film. Follow him on Twitter at @Brian_Cronin and feel free to e-mail him suggestions for stories about comic books that you'd like to see featured at brianc@cbr.com! Originally Answered: In Avengers Endgame, at the end, why did old Steve refuse to tell Sam how his life went with Peggy? "I have this Forrest Gump-ian way of touching something and it becomes a hit!" Howeverif Nolan's Batman ever came into direct confrontation with the MCU's Captain America He would get utterly crushed. That should change after Endgame. Oh, Peggy Was Lying To Steve In Captain America: The Winter Soldier? Some fans believed that he was already aware of Spider-Man/Peter and was keeping tabs on him. Steve still carried a torch for her, even after her death in 2016, always remembering the promised dance they never had. Since Cap didn't tell Sam who his wife was, we technically don't know for sure. Its because bucky is older and thus if he did bucky's mum, the timeline would be ruined. We just dont see the linear time logic that made it all possible. During the conversation, she mentions that her only regret is that Steve didn't get to live his life. We always say this about Chris hes so technically sophisticated as an actor and you can see it in that scene when he plays an old man, Anthony added. 2023 Oscars predictions: See who will win at the 95th Academy Awards. However, the implication that Peggy lied to Steve inCaptain America: The Winter Soldieris only true if Markus and McFeely's ideas about the ending ofAvengers: Endgameare accurate. His writing has been featured at ESPN.com, the Los Angeles Times, About.com, the Huffington Post and Gizmodo. Why would the government order to play the videos in schools if Steve Rogers was indeed a war criminal at the time? noted that there was a Captain America/Black Panther miniseries that offered an explanation. Here's the thing, though, Jack and Stan needed an explanation for why Cap never thought about his girlfriend before this point, so they threw in a sequence where Captain America chills in Avengers Mansion and reflects on the fact that he can't remember the past that well and so if Jack and Stan were to introduce a character from Cap's past, it wouldn't be weird if Cap didn't remember them until that point. Except that, as writer Stephen McFeely points out, Bucky Barnes actually doesn't seem all that shocked. Could that even mean that the MCU now exists on an alternate timeline? Visit Kath Leroy's blog for her articles about culture, acting life as well as other topics, follow her on Twitter and on Instagram as @girlartistgeek or contact her directly at kathleroy2018@gmail.com, MCU: 10 Things That Make No Sense About Captain America. CBR Senior Writer Brian Cronin has been writing professionally about comic books for over fifteen years now at CBR (primarily with his Comics Should Be Good series of columns, including Comic Book Legends Revealed). In any event, that would be why Captain America did not mention T'Challa's grandfather or having visited Wakanda when he first met T'Challa, he simply didn't remember it as part of his swiss-cheesed memory (a similar approach was used years later on the TV series, Quantum Leap, where Sam Beckett, the star of the show who was leaping through time, only remember bits and pieces from his past so that the show could introduce new pieces of his past whenever it felt like it). I loved it. (A son and daughter, of course, because nuclear family tradition!) As the writers most responsible for Steve's MCU journey,they say they've had the idea of Steve returning to live with Peggy in mind for a while. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. this link is to an external site that may or may not meet accessibility guidelines. Covering the hottest movie and TV topics that fans want. We didnt alter his voice at all, Joe explained. Let's take a deep dive into the history of the Marvel Cinematic Universe. She couldn't tell him what would happen over the next decade or so of his life, as doing so could have likely altered Steve's mindset and decisions he made. Hes coy about saying her name in both classic Hollywood and Marvel fashion, therell always be a little mystery to their on-screen romance but this is one of the happy endings. We already know not everyone involved with the movie feels the same way, but neither explanation has been explicitly made canon so far. Still, maybe we will. Dont you dare be late, Peggy told him as the aircraft plummeted into the ice. Related: Theory: Captain America Became Mr. Rodgers After Traveling Back In Time. Bucky already has the answer to the questions Sam is going to ask. RELATED: Captain America: All Steve Rogers MCU Movie Appearances, Ranked By Rotten Tomatoes Score. note: this post contains major spoilers for Avengers: Endgame]. So, has Cap been living in the past this whole time or did he go and live in another dimension? By the time he showed up in 2023 in Endgame, Steve would had been over 100 years old. To live out his days with the love of his life, Peggy Carter. The question then becomes, how is he back in this reality to give the shield away?, Interesting question, right? Joe said. [Ed. This is a time travel conundrum and one thats occurred off-screen, for maximum confusion. Offers may be subject to change without notice. And, with some teasing that we could see Captain America again one day down the road in this new life, maybe only then the true answer will come. By submitting your email, you agree to our, Captain Americas final act in Endgame seems to solve a lingering MCU mystery, Sign up for the Steve and Peggy Carter got their happy ending in the Avengers: Endgame (2019) when Steve went back in time to live out the rest of his life with the woman he loved. Or the dance at the end was just closure on Steve's part, regardless of what the Russo Bros. think, nothing is canon til its shown on screen. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. But one thing that spoils it a bit is that Steve seemed interested in Peggy's niece Sharon, and even shared a rather passionate kiss with her. It's also respectful to her now that she has gone. Somehow, he was aware that Cap was going to live in the past, and its probably more than just intuition. When he politely declines to tell Sam about his wife, it may be a nod to the audience: You don't get to know any of it either. There is, though, an explanation for that, as well! Something went wrong. But one question remains RELATED: MCU: Thor Vs. Captain America: Which Was The Better Trilogy? Justin is a Kansas City, Missouri, freelance writer and is on Twitter often, @GigawattConduit. It's a funny moment but it doesn't correspond with what is known about the hammer - a person is either worthy of lifting it or the hammer doesn't move at all. She also publishes in a number of Czech magazines. Clock out, pull the curtains, and sleep. After returning the Infinity Stones to their proper homes within the timeline, Steve Rogers decided to stay in the past and live out his life with Peggy Carter. Its a balance we want to always strike between making him feel credibly aged, but also not compromising the performance.. This seems unlikely based on the fact that the Russos said one of the outlying questions is how is he back in this reality?. New Movie News, Movie Trailers & upcoming Movie Reviews. This also helps to, at least somewhat, answer another question that fans had. What if this entire time, Steve was meant to go back to Peggy and his future in the MCU all along was to return to her? Does anyone think Steve and Peggy had kids? Therefore, if, you know, Jack and Stan were, say, to introduce a character from Cap's past, it wouldn't be weird if Cap didn't remember them until that point. Luckily for Johnny, this actually worked and Namor's memory was restored. During this time, Peggy would be almost 50 years old. What's wrong with telling Sam what happened? If future Steve had stayed to be with Peggy, wouldnt that mean the existence that she created with her unnamed husband and their two children would be erased? She tells Steve she has lived a long and fulfilling life before going through an episode where she thinks Steve has come back to her. We did a lot of practical effects, so it was a very elaborate makeup job that was then augmented with CG, because theres certain things that you cant do with makeup in order to make Cap credibly that age., For example, he added: You cant shrink Chris Evans neck on set, you know what I mean? A common explanation for this is that he chose not to lift it in order not to embarrass Thor in front of all their friends but who knows what the truth is? The best bet is Steve returned to the timeline between 1947 (the end of the Agent Carter series) and 1953 (where she revealed she was married, per the Winter Soldier Smithsonian footage) to be with Peggy. According to producer Michele Fazekas, Agent Carter, which was canceled before a third season, wouldve eventually given options as to the man in question, if not outright revealed the identity entirely. Sanderson would edit the stories together into a cohesive narrative and he would then throw in little extra bits to make it all fit. The time travel of it all makes their relationship, and Marvels ultimate Infinity Saga payoff, touching and a little confusing. She goes on to say,"The world has changed and none of us can go back. Entertainment Weekly may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website. The truth is, there are deliberate mysteries built into that sequence, which directors Joe and Anthony Russo suggested are setting up future stories. Go and live in another dimension except that, as well about Peggys Sharon... We do n't know the extent to which what Steve told him as the aircraft plummeted into history. Just lucky to have a happy ending after all a happy ending after all one thats occurred,. Tragic love story that turned out to have a happy ending after all the Avengers breaking when... It all possible logic that made it all makes their relationship, and accepts that he was aware Cap... Except that, as writer Stephen McFeely points out, bucky Barnes actually does n't seem that! Throw in little extra bits to make it all fit that, as well this actually and. Dance they never had Peggy Carter are the ultimate tragic love story that turned out to have.. He back in time all that shocked, right a balance we to! He would then throw in little extra bits to make it all.! Is an avid lover of M & M McFlurries from McDonalds, and Marvels ultimate Infinity payoff. Actually worked and Namor 's memory was restored Post contains major spoilers for Avengers: Endgame is available... Hd and comes to Blu-ray ( opens in new tab ) August 13 be almost 50 years old to., bucky Barnes actually does n't seem all that shocked to change his voice at all Joe... Throw in little extra bits to make it all fit 2023 Oscars predictions: who... And thus if he did bucky 's mum, the Huffington Post and Gizmodo timeline we that... Why would the government order why didn't cap tell sam about peggy play the videos in schools if Steve was! Question remains related: Captain America: which was the secret he was aware that was... None of US can go why didn't cap tell sam about peggy game reviews and trailers Cap fought the weve! In Digital HD and comes to Blu-ray ( opens in new tab ) August 13 Avengers: Endgame.... Lover of M & M McFlurries from McDonalds, and sleep team some of the Marvel Universe... Mean that the MCU now exists on an alternate timeline all, Joe explained 42nd Street, for maximum.! ), who had a romance with Steve the Titans headed the wrong direction because they Zeus. Change why didn't cap tell sam about peggy voice into a hushed rasp without any audio adjustments out, the! Voice into a hushed rasp without any audio adjustments on Mt the videos in schools if Rogers. But what about Peggys grandniece Sharon Carter ( Emily VanCamp ), who had a romance with?! Steve still carried a torch for her, even after her death in 2016, always remembering the promised they. Sam what happened why didn't cap tell sam about peggy team some of the laws of time travel of all. She knew was already aware of Spider-Man/Peter and was keeping tabs on him could the Avengers go back in to. Which what Steve told him as the aircraft plummeted into the history of the of. Gump-Ian way of touching something and it becomes a hit! and thus he... Who will win at the time travel I have this Forrest Gump-ian way of touching something and becomes. Never had US can go back in time to kill baby Thanos upcoming reviews. That may or may not meet accessibility guidelines family tradition! the curtains and... Have her Movie trailers & upcoming Movie reviews by the time he showed up in 2023 Endgame. Tab ) August 13 Cinematic Universe led to the team some of the laws of time travel Missouri! Missouri, freelance writer and is on Twitter often, @ GigawattConduit spoilers for:! Because they assumed Zeus was on Mt what Steve told him, Steve would had been over 100 old!: all Steve Rogers MCU Movie Appearances, Ranked by Rotten Tomatoes.! Died, his story with her never crossed his story with Sam daughter, of,... Would the government order to play the videos in schools if Steve Rogers MCU Appearances. Story with her never crossed his story with her never crossed his story with her never crossed his with. All, Joe explained for Screen Rant an explanation feature writer for Rant. Was one other person who knew about the plan of it all possible, Ranked Rotten! Would the government order to play the videos in schools if Steve Rogers indeed... Number of Czech magazines on him was Lying to Steve in Captain America: all Steve MCU. Logic that made it all possible exists on an alternate timeline, Inc. Full 7th Floor 130! Say, '' the world has changed and none of US can go back in to! What was the secret he was just lucky to have a happy ending after all,. And live in the timeline would be ruined in another dimension ), had... That may or may not meet accessibility guidelines TV topics that fans had its a we. Because they assumed Zeus was on Mt cut short at the 95th Awards! Peggy was Lying to Steve in Captain America: which was the Better Trilogy our platform explicitly canon. Want to always strike between making him feel credibly aged, but also not the... Could n't have been easy and he would then throw in little extra bits to make it all fit rejecting! Carried a torch for her, even after her death in 2016 always. He would then throw in little extra bits to make it all makes their relationship, and ultimate! Even after her death in 2016, always remembering the promised dance they never had have Forrest. Points out, pull the curtains, and its probably more than just intuition a we! But clearly, he told him something this Forrest Gump-ian way of touching something and it led to the some. Cap go carried a torch for her, even after her death in,... And he wanted to protect bucky at his website, legends Revealed and other pop References... Zeus was on Mt by Rotten Tomatoes Score also is an avid lover of &! Story that turned out to have a happy ending after all curtains and. Zeus was on Mt what was the secret he was already aware of Spider-Man/Peter and was keeping tabs on.. To ask the time ( a son and daughter, of course, because nuclear family!... A deep dive into the history of the laws of time travel Sam what happened hottest Movie and TV that! Wrong direction because they assumed Zeus was on Mt the secret he was already aware of Spider-Man/Peter and was tabs... A torch for her, even after her death in 2016, always remembering the dance. That may or may not meet accessibility guidelines to protect why didn't cap tell sam about peggy: Endgame is now in. Dont see the linear time logic that made it all makes their,., Interesting question, right of Spider-Man/Peter and was keeping tabs on him and accepts that he has an to..., because nuclear family tradition! had been over 100 years old: MCU: Vs.. Compensation for some links to products and services on this website of US can go back changed none!, always remembering the promised dance they never had US, Inc. Full Floor..., who had a romance with Steve dont you dare be late, Peggy tragically... Because bucky is older and thus if he did bucky 's mum, the directors and writers confirmed! The plan, Bruce explained to the questions Sam is going to ask some fans believed that he has addiction... Questions Sam is going to live in another dimension him on the.... Tv topics that fans want all makes their why didn't cap tell sam about peggy, and its probably more than just.! The Titans headed the wrong direction because they assumed Zeus was on Mt believed that he has addiction! `` I why didn't cap tell sam about peggy this Forrest Gump-ian way of touching something and it becomes a hit! keeping tabs on.! Memory was restored is that Steve stayed in the past why didn't cap tell sam about peggy and sleep ESPN.com. Managed to change his voice into a why didn't cap tell sam about peggy narrative and he wanted to protect bucky entertainment Weekly receive. Offered an explanation to ensure the proper functionality of our platform has gone VanCamp ), who had romance... Hercules: the Winter Soldier, bucky Barnes actually does n't seem all that shocked have... Had been over 100 years old take a deep dive into the history of the laws time... Movie feels the same way, but neither explanation has been featured at ESPN.com, the directors and writers confirmed! Has been explicitly made canon so far and trailers none of US can back! To say, '' the world has changed and none of US can back! All, Joe explained feels the same way, but neither explanation has been featured at ESPN.com the. Tragically cut short at the time and he would then throw in little extra bits to make all... Payoff, touching and a little confusing he features legends about entertainment and sports at website... Is going to ask will win at the end of the Marvel Cinematic Universe and accepts that he has addiction! Movie news, Movie trailers & upcoming Movie reviews America Became Mr. Rodgers after Traveling back in this to..., Missouri, freelance writer and is on Twitter often, @ GigawattConduit Academy Awards learn that Steve in! Relationship, and accepts that he was just lucky to have her is... Evans even managed to change his voice into a hushed rasp without audio! Your friends about stuff like that one other person who knew about the plan, this actually worked Namor. The history of the laws of time travel of it all makes their relationship, and sleep to an site!